Is metal roofing worth it in Alabama?

For most North Alabama homeowners planning to stay long-term, metal roofing is worth the higher upfront cost. It lasts 40–70 years versus 20–30 for shingles, requires zero maintenance, is more resistant to hail and high winds, and reduces cooling costs. The break-even point versus shingles is typically reached within one roof replacement cycle.

How does metal roofing hold up to hail in Alabama?

Snap-lock metal roofing is rated for winds up to 150+ MPH and handles hail significantly better than asphalt shingles. Shingles can lose granules and sustain impact damage from hail that registers as a valid insurance claim. Metal panels typically show less damage under the same conditions. Impact-resistant shingles (Class IV) offer improved hail resistance over standard shingles at a lower cost than metal.

Which is cheaper: metal or shingles?

Shingles are cheaper upfront. In Huntsville, AL, architectural shingles start around $385/sq versus $840/sq for snap-lock metal. However, metal roofing lasts two to three times longer than shingles, so the lifetime cost can be lower when you factor in the cost of one or two additional shingle replacements over the same timeframe.

All guides

Buying Guide·6 min read

Metal vs. Shingles: Which Roof Is Right for North Alabama?

Alabama's weather is hard on roofs. Here's how to decide between metal and shingles based on your home, your budget, and how long you plan to stay.

Choosing between shingles and metal is the most common decision BayCo homeowners face. Both are good options. The right one depends on your budget, how long you plan to stay in the home, and what matters most to you in a roof.

Here's how the two perform in North Alabama specifically, and how to think through the decision.

How North Alabama's climate affects your choice

Huntsville and Madison sit in a part of the country that sees real weather: hail storms in spring, high winds, occasional ice, and summers that push heat into the attic. Your roofing material has to handle all of it.

Hail: Asphalt shingles lose granules from hail impact. Enough damage triggers an insurance claim and often a replacement. Snap-lock metal and Class IV impact-resistant shingles handle hail significantly better.
Wind: Both premium shingles (160 MPH rated per ASTM D3161 Class F) and metal (150+ MPH) hold up well in Alabama wind events. Standard shingles (130 MPH) are the most vulnerable.
Heat: Metal roofing reflects more solar energy than asphalt, reducing attic heat buildup. Cool-roof rated snap-lock metal can cut cooling costs 10–25% over the summer. (Oak Ridge National Laboratory)
Ice & moisture: Metal sheds water and ice more effectively than shingles. Proper installation with high-density underlayment matters for both.

Cost comparison

Upfront, shingles are less expensive. But the full-lifetime math looks different:

Standard shingles: $385/sq · 20–25 year lifespan
Premium shingles: $425/sq · 25–30 year lifespan
Snap-lock metal: $840/sq · 40–70 year lifespan

A homeowner who installs shingles today may replace the roof once or twice more before a metal roof installed at the same time would need attention. Over 50 years, the total cost of two or three shingle replacements can exceed the cost of one metal installation.

Shingles are the right call if…

You want a quality roof at an accessible price point
You plan to stay in the home for 10–20 more years, but not necessarily forever
You're working within a tighter budget or are more focused on monthly cash flow
You want the most popular, widely-understood roofing product in North Alabama

Metal is the right call if…

This is your forever home and you want the last roof you'll ever install
You want zero maintenance: no granule loss, no annual inspections, no patching
Energy efficiency is a priority (metal runs cooler in Alabama summers)
You're in a severe weather zone and want the best protection from hail and wind
You want a roof that increases resale value over the long term

What about specialty metal?

BayCo also offers specialty metal profiles (KasselWood steel shingles, Rustic Shake aluminum, and GrandeTile) for homeowners who want the durability of metal with the appearance of wood shake, clay tile, or traditional shingles. These carry lifetime warranties and are a strong choice for high-end homes or HOA communities with aesthetic requirements. Pricing is custom and requires a consultation.

“Metal isn't for everyone, and I tell people that. But if you're planning to stay in your home long-term and you've already replaced your shingles once, the math on metal starts looking very different. You're not paying more, you're paying once.”
Jarrett Bailey, Owner, BayCo Roofing

The bottom line

Neither shingles nor metal is wrong. Both are installed on thousands of Huntsville homes every year. The difference is your timeline and your priorities.

If you want to compare them side by side for your specific home, BayCo can produce estimates for both in the same visit, so you have a real number for each option before you decide.

Ready to get a metal roof? See BayCo's metal roofing service or book a free inspection.

Ready to get a real number for your home?

Digital quotes in 2 hours. No appointment, no sales call.